Beware the Dangers in This Move to Safety
By Rev Shark
RealMoney.com Contributor
3/13/2006 9:08 AM EST
"To be really great in little things, to be truly noble and heroic in the insipid details of everyday life, is a virtue so rare as to be worthy of canonization."
-- Harriet Beecher Stowe
There are times when close analysis of the major indices is of great help in positioning yourself appropriately. If you are in tune with the DJIA, S&P 500 and Nasdaq then you should be able to come up with a good strategy for how to proceed. This is not one of those times when the indices are of great help.
The action last week is a good illustration. If you simply looked at the DJIA or the S&P 500 you would think that the market is in pretty darn good shape. Both of the major indices have their beady little eyes focused on recent highs and haven't even pulled back enough to warrant being called a pullback.
If you formulate your overall view of the market by simply considering the technical conditions of the S&P 500 or the DJIA you would most likely maintain a bullish bias. But as the saying goes, the devil is in the details. The action in many of the stocks that have been the strongest over the past three to six months was very poor. Many of these high-beta, momentum and small-cap stocks were aggressively sold. In addition, commodity and energy-related stocks that had the best relative strength for some time were pummeled.
What exactly is going on here? The major indices look pretty darn good but an analysis of the action under the surface exposes some cracks. The most logical explanation is that the market is undergoing some sort of rotation or change of character. There is reshuffling taking place that you can't see unless you go beyond the big indices.
One of the most obvious changes is the move to safety. The stodgy big-caps with lower volatility are what drive the major indices and they are obviously attracting some of the money that is coming out of the more volatile, high-growth names. The problem with this movement to safety and security means that the speculative forces that produce strong market action are weak. People who are heavily bullish don't flock to Johnson & Johnson (JNJ:NYSE) and General Electric (GE:NYSE) instead of high-beta technology stocks. A move to "safety" can pull the big indices up but as we've seen, it means that breadth is likely to narrow and that smaller, more speculative stocks will be punished.
Many on Wall Street are very attached to the idea of a rotation into blue chip stocks -- which they have been predicting for the last eight or so years without success. Many of the Wall Street Whales have no choice but to buy the stodgy behemoths, and the idea that they may finally see some relative strength is of great appeal to the big brokers, funds and analysts.
Transitions of this sort are never easy and in many cases the market has already gone too far in dumping old leaders and moving into new ones. Apple (AAPL:Nasdaq), for example, has been badly hit on no significant fundamental news and is seeing some upgrades this morning as a result.
Whether this move to safety will continue or whether this pessimism will eventually lead to a broader market decline is certainly not clear. Negativity remains quite high but many folks don't see it because of the effect the move to safety has had on the big indices. How can we say there is negativity if the DJIA is heading for highs? Just dig in a bit deeper and you will see it.
I'm somewhat of a market agnostic now. Enough technical damage was done to temper my bullishness but the negativity and the degree of the punishment that has already been done is keeping me from embracing the ursine side of things. I'm staying focused on the details of my individual positions and will formulate my approach based on that.
We have an upbeat start to the day after some merger-and-acquisition news over the weekend. The thinking is that if companies are willing to buy other companies, then valuations can't be that bad. Both Europe and Asia were strong overnight, oil is down and the dollar is strong.
No positions in stocks mentioned.